United States Attorney David J. Freed said the charges of the indictment were handed down based on the belief that Gartland headed up a plan to defraud two health care benefit programs, Wellspan Health of York, PA and Medicare, by writing 221 prescriptions written in the names of three of his family members between the dates of September 2014 and August 2017. The prescriptions were for the opiates Hydrocodone, Oxycodone, Fentanyl, Morphine and other controlled substances. The majority of the prescriptions were written for Hydrocodone-Ibuprofen.
The indictment notes that the prescriptions were not written for treatment of the family members but rather for the personal use of Dr. Gartland. Because of this, the prescriptions were not written in the realm of professional medical practice and were not used for a medical reason.